Hi everyone, please welcome my friend, philologist, bassoon player, fellow baker and latest Cupcake Avenger guest blogger Molly Miller and her lemon lime bars!
So, I decided to make these. I had more limes than I knew what to do with, and I was excited to try a new type of recipe, having never attempted lemon squares before. I did not follow instructions, so I will go ahead and rewrite them to show my process. Feel free to follow the original recipe without my commentary to distract you.
Get a 13x9 inch pan and line it with something. I was told to use foil, but I somehow ended up with 3 boxes of parchment paper in my drawer, so I decided to use some of it up and they came out of the pan just fine. Sometimes, it seems like people are using foil and parchment paper because they just want to reduce the amount of cleanup or be extra careful, but I think you do need to line the pan here if you want to remove the bars without cracking the crust. Do it.
2/3 cup unsalted butter at room temperature
1/2 cup packed golden brown sugar
2 cups all purpose flour (I used white whole wheat flour, and it was delicious.)
Zest of 1 large lemon (or three small limes, if that's what you have.)
Cream together the butter and the sugar and the zest, and then add the flour. It will end up crumbly, so you can smash it into your pan for your crust. I've never tried to do that before, so my crust wasn't as pretty as it could have been, but it held together nicely.
"Bake 20 minutes at 350, or until center is set." (I overbaked mine. 20 minutes seems insane. Remember that the crust will get baked AGAIN, and you don't want your edges to get too dark like mine did.)
At first I was a little annoyed that I would have to make a crust AND a filling, but then I realized that there was absolutely no reason to wash my mixing bowl and beaters between the crust and the filling. Yay less work!
My recipe told me to hang out and wait while the crust is baking, but really, you should get started on zesting and juicing those lemons and limes. I did not have any lemons, so these are going to mainly be lime bars. Instead of a quarter cup of lemon juice and a quarter cup of lime juice, I juiced between 1/3 and 1/2 cup of lime juice and filled the rest of the 1/2 cup with bottled lemon juice from my fridge and a splash of lemon extract for good measure. I zested a bunch of limes until it looked like I had at least a teaspoon (there's a picture of how much I used) and ignored the bit about the lemon zest. My bars taste like lime and are delicious, but if you like lemon too, go ahead and adjust lemon/lime proportions as you like.
6 large eggs
2 1/4 cup granulated sugar
1/2 cup all purpose flour (I used white whole wheat.)
3/4 teaspoon baking powder
1/4 cup lemon juice and 1/4 cup lime juice (or some combination thereof)
zest of 1 large lemon (unless you don't have any)
1 teaspoon lime zest
1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg
My recipe encouraged me to add a drop or two of food coloring to make them pretty, but I just plain forgot. I'm content with the color I ended up with, but go ahead and throw some extra coloring in if you want them to look a little more cheerful.
(Side note: Cooking with The Spatula of Love will make your food delicious and give you the right to brag that you put so much love into your baking that you had to use a special spatula to control it.)
After 20 minutes, the filling had a crust over the top, but the contents were still sloshing around beneath it. I realized my oven thermometer was reading 300 instead of 350, so I adjusted things and popped them back in. After 5 minutes, I didn't exactly know how to tell whether they were done or not. Is the center set? Well, my toothpick came out clean and nothing was sloshy, so it might be done, right? But, I hate cutting into something after it has cooled only to realize that I have undercooked it, so I turned off the oven and stuck it in for a few more minutes. After letting them cool a bit on the counter, you should cover them and let them chill in the fridge for 2 hours. Then, sprinkle with powdered sugar (and more zest, if you're not sick of zesting yet. I was.)
At some point, I scooped a bit of something weird looking (undermixed egg?) off the top of the bars and left a small hole behind, as you can see in the pictures. The powdered sugar covered it, so no worries. I've included a picture of the uglier edge pieces as a warning against making the crust climb too high and then baking it for longer than you might need to.
I stored my leftovers in the fridge and they were still delicious a week later, though you might have to refresh the powdered sugar if you want them to look pretty after sitting in the fridge for a few days.